Carthage vs Otterbein: Softball Program Comparison
Two D3 programs. Otterbein runs $1,583 less per year; Otterbein graduates 8 points more of its students.
Which one is right for you?
Neither school is better in the abstract — they are better for different athletes. These are the differences big enough to actually decide on.
Lean Carthage if…
- You are weighing the degree as an investment: Carthage graduates earn about $3,637 more per year a decade after enrolling.
Lean Otterbein if…
- The number on the bill matters: Otterbein lists $1,583 less per year in tuition and housing than Carthage, and neither charges by residency.
- Finishing the degree is the priority: Otterbein graduates 8 percentage points more of its students than Carthage.
What it costs to go there
Published sticker price from IPEDS. Almost nobody pays it — athletic, academic and need-based aid all come off the top — but the gap between two schools is a fair read on the gap between two offers.
| Measure | Carthage | Otterbein |
|---|---|---|
| Tuition & feesBoth schools charge one rate regardless of residency. | $36,500 | $34,899 — Otterbein leads on this measure: lower published tuition |
| Room & board | $12,950 | $12,968 |
| Est. year, all inTuition & fees plus room & board. Excludes books, travel and any aid. | $49,450 | $47,867 — Otterbein leads on this measure: lower total cost per year |
What you leave with
Federal College Scorecard figures for all students at the institution, not softball players specifically. Read them as a signal about the degree, not about the program.
| Measure | Carthage | Otterbein |
|---|---|---|
| Graduation rate | 61% | 69% — Otterbein leads on this measure: higher share of students finishing their degree |
| Median earnings, 10 years after entry | $56,950/yr — Carthage leads on this measure: higher median earnings a decade out | $53,313/yr |
| Median debt at graduation | $26,000 | $26,000 |
| Debt as a share of year-10 payMedian debt divided by median earnings 10 years after entry. Lower is easier to pay back. | 46% — Carthage leads on this measure: debt is a smaller share of what graduates earn | 49% |
Getting in, and what you'd walk into
Admissions and size. A coach can support your file, but at most schools they cannot admit you — the academic profile below is the bar you still have to clear.
| Measure | Carthage | Otterbein |
|---|---|---|
| Admission rateLower means more selective — harder to get in, but not automatically the better fit. | 87% | 85% |
| Total enrollmentNeither is better — it is the difference between a lecture hall and a seminar table. | 2,771 | 2,357 |
| Where it is | Kenosha, WI | Westerville, OH |
The softball program itself
Division and conference set the ceiling; the postseason record and staff tell you what the program has actually done with it.
| Measure | Carthage | Otterbein |
|---|---|---|
| Conference | CCIW | OAC |
| Head coach | Cindy Carpenter | Bruce Anderson |
How you actually get in front of them
Camps and questionnaires are the two channels a recruit controls. Where a program runs its own camp, that camp is usually the shortest path to being evaluated by the staff that would recruit you.
| Measure | Carthage | Otterbein |
|---|---|---|
| Recruiting questionnaire | Yes | Yes |
| Program on X / Instagram | — | Yes |
Scholarship money, honestly
Both programs sit at NCAA Division III, so the scholarship rules are identical: 0 (no athletic scholarships). There are no athletic scholarships at D3 — by rule. But D3 schools often award generous academic merit and need-based aid that can rival an athletic scholarship elsewhere.
What to do about it this week
Questionnaires are exempt from NCAA contact-date rules, so you can submit one at any age. Do both, then follow with a short email to each staff.
Carthage
Open the recruiting questionnaireCamps we track
None listed right now. Camp schedules go up through the winter — check the program's own site before ruling it out.
Otterbein
Open the recruiting questionnaireCamps we track
None listed right now. Camp schedules go up through the winter — check the program's own site before ruling it out.
Carthage vs Otterbein: common questions
- Is Carthage or Otterbein cheaper?
- On published price, Otterbein is cheaper — about $47,867 a year in tuition and housing, against $49,450 at Carthage. That is sticker price; athletic, academic and need-based aid all come off it, so ask both coaches what an actual offer would look like.
- Which school graduates more of its students, Carthage or Otterbein?
- Otterbein, at 69% against 61% at Carthage (IPEDS, 2023-24). That is the whole student body, not the softball roster.
- Do Carthage and Otterbein offer softball scholarships?
- Both play at NCAA Division III: 0 (no athletic scholarships). There are no athletic scholarships at D3 — by rule. But D3 schools often award generous academic merit and need-based aid that can rival an athletic scholarship elsewhere.
- How do I contact the coaches at Carthage and Otterbein?
- Both programs run a recruiting questionnaire, and that is the right first move — it is exempt from NCAA contact-date rules, so you can submit it at any age. Fill out both, then follow with an email to each staff.
Cost, graduation and enrollment figures from IPEDS (U.S. Dept. of Education, 2023-24). Earnings, debt and admission rates from the federal College Scorecard. Postseason results from the NCAA Division I softball tournament records, 2021-2026. Rankings from NCAA.com and U.S. News & World Report. Figures describe the institution, not the softball roster.
We work hard to keep all data for Carthage and Otterbein accurate and up-to-date, but we sometimes miss changes or get something wrong.
Still deciding between them?
Track both programs, log every coach you contact, and see where you actually stand against each one's recruiting profile.
Start free